NikonGear'23
Gear Talk => Lens Talk => Topic started by: Michael Erlewine on August 10, 2017, 09:25:24
-
In Praise of the APO-El Nikkor 105mm
I cannot say enough about the fine qualities of the APO-Nikkor 105mm enlarger lens. I would not even think of using a lens as slow as the APO-El Nikkor (f/5.6), but I have no problem using this lens and I do almost every day. It is that good. In fact, the more I use it, the more I want to use it. It has a style all its own, one that calls out for me to try this, that, and then some other thing with it.
The lens is very sharp, but in a very organic way that does not appear as cold or cut and dried. Its color is superb, perhaps because it is so very well corrected. And you don’t want to confuse with its younger brother the APO-El Nikkor 105mm lens that is not APO (apochromatic). They are not in the same ballpark.
Perhaps every photographer finds one lens that just fits them to a “T” and this may be mine. It’s not that I don’t have (and love!) many other lenses, but for some reason this little gem is undeniable. And I have to use it on a bellows, with what that entails, so it’s not a slam-dunk.
And while I love the Zeiss Otus lenses, the Voigtlander 125mm APO-Lanthar and on and on, I’ve yet to find a more compelling lens than the APO-El Nikkor 105mm. And I also took the time (years) to seek out its big brother the APO-El Nikkor 210mm lens and found one. It is just a much larger and heavier version of the APO-105mm. There is nothing better about the 210 than the 105mm. I decided to sell it because of its bulk, but I wish I had a backup copy of my APO-El Nikkor 105mm.
Photographers speak of certain lenses having a unique “style.” IMO, the legendary Noct Nikkor is one of those or the Voigtlander 125mm APO-Lanthar. The APO-El Nikkor 105mm is one of those special lenses. I can’t put my finger on what makes this lens’s style so exceptional, but there it is. Perhaps one of you out there who have used this lens can explain it to me.
And it is so flexible. In fact, this lens caused me to get a much longer rail (and bellows) for my Cambo Mini-Actus, so that could pull back and get closer.
Here is a shot I took yesterday with the Nikon D810, using the APO-El Nikkor 105mm
-
Another magnificent photo. There's little more to say ...
I agree with you about the way that detail is precisely and beautifully rendered without looking "sharp".
Splendid!
John
-
Michael, I see why you praise the El Nikkor 105 APO.
Your skills should be equally praised.
-
The light is this image is quite exquisite and very well captured!
-
I love EL-Nikkors!!! :o :o :o
-
I love EL-Nikkors!!! :o :o :o
It is not an EL-Nikkor, it is an APO EL-Nikkor, world of a difference....
-
Wonderful work Michael, this lens really shines in your hands!
Happy to also own one... ;-)
PS: ehemm, if you would kindly write it "Apo-EL-NIKKOR" it would help people not to get confused about it, as the way you write it, it reads as if it is just an EL-NIKKOR that you found out being "APO". So why not just stick to the way Nikon engraved it to its front rim and avoid any such confusion as it just happened above?? ;-)
-
Wonderful work Michael, this lens really shines in your hands!
Happy to also own one... ;-)
PS: ehemm, if you would kindly write it "Apo-EL-NIKKOR" it would help people not to get confused about it, as the way you write it, it reads as if it is just an EL-NIKKOR that you found out being "APO". So why not just stick to the way Nikon engraved it to its front rim and avoid any such confusion as it just happened above?? ;-)
I get it. I could do that.
-
I get it. I could do that.
Thanks! Will help others... :-)
-
The lens is very sharp, but in a very organic way that does not appear as cold or cut and dried.
I agree. I would say that this lens, in your hands, has a richness that few lens have. Well done.
-
Michael,
nice to read (again) your praise of the APO-EL-Nikkor 105 mm,
(which is the lens you bought from me years ago now incl. custom lens-shade)
The colour-rendition and look and feel of this famous tiny lens
helps you to bring out your fantastic images -- its allways the photographer
If you find the time, perhaps you can show us comparisons (for bokeh and colour-rendition)
of the Apo-EL-Nikkor vs. the Voigtländer Apo-Lanthar 125 mm /f2.5
Best wishes,
Christian
-
Michael,
nice to read (again) your praise of the APO-EL-Nikkor 105 mm,
(which is the lens you bought from me years ago now incl. custom lens-shade)
The colour-rendition and look and feel of this famous tiny lens
helps you to bring out your fantastic images -- its allways the photographer
If you find the time, perhaps you can show us comparisons (for bokeh and colour-rendition)
of the Apo-EL-Nikkor vs. the Voigtländer Apo-Lanthar 125 mm /f2.5
Best wishes,
Christian
Thanks Christian. I may not have time or inclination to do that comparison just now, but I have published many photos using both of these fine lenses. The CV-125 is mounted on the camera, like any other lens, while the APO-El-Nikkor 105mm must use a bellows to get the most out of it. Both of these lenses have a unique character. I tend to use the APO-El Nikkor because I especially like it and also like to use the Tilt movements of a bellows with that lense.
-
I love the lighting and atmosphere captured in this image, needless to say about the sharpness.
As you would know, you can change the title the title of the thread by editing your initial post.
-
Keep coming back, in awe of these amazing image(s) you show using this marvel of a lens.
Need to get mine to work it seems... ;-)
-
Michael, thanks for editing the title!