NikonGear'23
Images => Critique => Topic started by: afx on September 13, 2015, 12:33:29
-
After leaving the restaurant in Roundstone, I went down the steps to the harbor:
(https://nikongear.net/revival/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.afximages.com%2Fphotos%2Fi-gxC4CFq%2F0%2FL%2Fi-gxC4CFq-L.jpg&hash=4d90386caadddeb751daf6bdde70d345e1ad48ab) (http://images.afximages.com/photos/i-gxC4CFq/0/O/i-gxC4CFq-O.jpg)
(https://nikongear.net/revival/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.afximages.com%2Fphotos%2Fi-nNLNqg4%2F0%2FL%2Fi-nNLNqg4-L.jpg&hash=c231b930c69f6112ff554c48f460645b410a1d09) (http://images.afximages.com/photos/i-nNLNqg4/0/O/i-nNLNqg4-O.jpg)
Apart from the simple color vs. BW question, what else could I have done differently? I could have moved to the left and right for a few meters, but fond that position the most interesting one.
cheers
afx
-
I like the 2nd one better, it is another picture
no birds and no 4th mast give the 3 main masts the dominance that makes it and bw give it a timeless look
-
Thanks, I'll try to crop the bird one so that the superfluous mast is out of the image, I think that will help it also.
cheers
afx
-
Why not leave the birds in the b&w version?
Makes the image a little more interesting IMO.
-
Hi Andreas,
I like the B&W version better. I think removal of the fourth mask helps. In the color image, the birds seem to be hardly differentiated from their background. I wonder if a B&W version of that image would change that tonal separation. Just my $.02 :)
Cheers,
-raaj
-
I think the fourth mast helps make it more interesting somehow and I like the birds ann b&w makes it timeless. I dislike the half boat on left 😉