Has the SL I a different filter thread? The SL II has a 52mm.
The SL I has a 49mm filter thread instead - same as the SL I 75/2.5 and 180/4.
As was mentioned already, a good hood option for the 90/3.5 SL II is the K5 ring (from the K ring extension tube set) The K5 is 20mm long, so will provide a useful amount of protection and shade to the front lens. It has 52mm filter threads at both ends so it can screw directly onto the lens, and accept a regular 52mm lens cap at the other end. Since it does not flare out it is relatively compact, so you could keep it on more or less permanently. You could even try adding the K4 ring (10mm) on as well, giving a 30mm deep hood, although I suspect this will cause vignetting on FX cameras.